Hozierovo „Would That I“ je bohatou tapisérií metafor a emocí, která spojuje témata lásky, ztráty a transformační síly obou. The song's lyrics are steeped in natural imagery, with references to trees, fire, and ash, which serve as metaphors for the cycles of love and the impact of its departure. The opening lines set the tone with a romantic vision of a woman's hair likened to a willow tree, suggesting a natural, free-flowing, and enchanting presence. Píseň se pak ponoří do bolesti z nepřítomnosti lásky a přirovnává ji ke stromu, který ví, že musí být pokácen, aby poskytl teplo. Toto hořkosladké uznání nezbytnosti lásky a její ceny je opakujícím se tématem celé písně.
The chorus contrasts the past with the present, indicating that the intense feelings of love ('set alight') and the comfort it brings ('hold me tight') are not part of the current moment. Tento refrén „ne dnes večer“ naznačuje touhu po minulé intenzitě, která již není dostupná. The repeated assurance that 'you're good to me' seems to be a grateful acknowledgment of love's enduring kindness, despite the changes over time. Vypravěčský oblouk písně provede posluchače cestou lásky, která jasně hoří, pak slábne a zanechává trvalý dopad na srdce.
Musically, Hozier is known for his soulful voice and his ability to blend elements of blues, folk, and indie rock into a unique sound that complements his poetic lyrics. 'Would That I' is no exception, with its haunting melody and Hozier's emotive delivery enhancing the song's themes. The song captures the universal experience of reflecting on past loves, the pain of letting go, and the warmth of cherished memories. Je to svědectví o trvalé síle lásky a o stopách, které na nás zanechává dlouho poté, co plameny utichly.